Child Abuse Caselaw Database

Malcolm Johnson & Co. specialises in child abuse compensation claims. Malcolm Johnson is one of the authors of the leading textbook in this field “Child Abuse Compensation Claims” and he lectures regularly for ACAL.

If you are seeking help with a specific claim please visit our child abuse compensation page.

Child abuse compensation claims are complex. They frequently involve difficult questions of limitation, negligence, causation and quantum. Over the years, the court have dealt with each of these issues and handed down judgments that have, to some extent, clarified the law in this area.

Some of the cases in this Database do not involve child abuse compensation claims, but they relate instead to issues of vicarious liability and limitation. These cases have been included because they relate to issues that impact on child abuse cases.

The Caselaw Database was set up to provide a detailed summary of each of these judgments. It has two main purposes:-

• The Database aims to provide practitioners with a series of signposts to the relevant cases and an overview of what the court is saying in each case.
• The Database aims to ensure that the staff of Malcolm Johnson & Co. knows the relevant law in this area and that our clients can rely on our expertise.

There is no charge for using the database, which is constantly being updated with new cases. Malcolm Johnson & Co. invites comments and suggestions from users, who should use the contact options to the right.

Guide to compensation

• Year
• Category
• Court

• 1909
• 1964
• 1972
• 1973
• 1985
• 1986
• 1987
• 1990
• 1991
• 1992
• 1993
• 1994
• 1995
• 1996
• 1997
• 1998
• 1999
• 2000
• 2001
• 2002
• 2003
• 2004
• 2005
• 2006
• 2007
• 2008
• 2009
• 2010
• 2011
• 2012

1909

• Yonge v Toynbee 1909

1964

• Rookes v Barnard 1964

1972

• R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board ex parte Staten 1972
• R v CICB ex parte Fox 1972

1973

• R v CICB ex parte Ince 1973

1985

• Sargent v Walsall Metropolitan Borough Council And Others 1985

1986

• R v CICB ex parte Webb and Others 1986

1987

• Arnold v Central Electricity Generating Board [1987]
• Hill v Chief Constable of West Yorkshire 1987

1990

• Donovan v Gwentoys Ltd 1990
• R v L.P.B 1990

1991

• Surtees v Kingston Upon Thames Borough Council 1991
• Halford v Brooks and Another 1991
• R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board ex parte Wilson 1991

1992

• Hartley v Birmingham City District Council 1992
• R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board ex parte 20th February 1992

1993

• Blamire v South Cumbria Health Authority 1993
• Stubbings v Webb 1993
• Re G (A Ward)(Criminal Injuries Compensation)1993
• Nash and Others v Eli Lilly & Co. and Others 1993
• R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board ex parte Maxted
• R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board ex parte Powell 1993
• Re G (a ward) (Criminal Injuries : Compensation) 1993
• R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board 1993
• R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board 1993

1994

• Dobbie v Medway Health Authority 1994
• S v W [1994]
• Broadley V Guy Clapham & Co. 1994
• Yates v Thakeham Tiles Limited 1994
• Whitfield v North Durham Health Authority 1994
• RP and TG v Home Office and CICB 1994

1995

• X (Minors) v Bedfordshire County Council, M (A Minor) And Another v Newham London Borough Council And Others, E (A Minor) v Dorset County Council, Chirstmas v Hampshire County Council, Keating v Bromley London Borough Council 1995
• Griffiths v Williams 1995
• R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board ex parte 1995
• R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board ex parte Dickenson 1995
• R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board ex parte Cobb 1995

1996

• Various Claimants v Leicestershire County Council 1996
• Forbes v Wandsworth Health Authority 1996
• Coad v Cornwall and Isles of Scilly Health Authority 1996
• Stubbings and Others v United Kingdom 1996
• R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board ex parte Reid 1996
• R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board ex parte Cook 1996
• R v CICB ex parte Richardson [1996] CLY 1447

1997

• H v Norfolk 1997
• Farthing v North East Essex Health Authority 1997
• R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board ex parte Brown Murphy 1997
• R v CICB ex parte Piercy 1997
• P’s Curator Bonis v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board 1997
• P’s Curator Bonis v CICB 1997

1998

• W 1 – 6 v Essex County Council and Another 1998
• Phelps v London Borough of Hillingdon 1998
• A B & Others v Liverpool City Council, The Nugent Care Society, Trustees of The National Children’s Home and Orphanage Registered 1998
• Osman v United Kingdom 1998
• R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Authority ex Parte Leatherland 1998
• R v CICB ex parte Kent and Milne
• R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board ex parte JM B-M 1998

1999

• Barrett v London Borough Of Enfield 1999
• Bazley v Curry 1999
• Jacobi v Griffiths 1999
• Das v Ganju 1999
• Long v Tolchard & Sons Ltd 1999
• Regina v CICB ex parte A House of Lords 25th March 1999
• R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board ex parte Salt 1999
• X v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board 1999
• R v Secretary of State for Home Department, ex parte C 1999
• R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board ex parte Walls 1999
• LC v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board 1999
• X v CICB 1999
• Stuart v United Kingdom 1999

2000

• W 1 – 6 v Essex County Council and Another 2000
• Phelps v London Borough of Hillingdon, Anderton v Clwyd County Council, in Re G (A Minor) By His Next Friend, Jarvis v Hampshire County Council [2000]
• S v Gloucestershire County Council; L v The London Borough of Tower Hamlets and London Borough of Havering [2000]
• Various Claimants v Flintshire County Council 2000
• Brooks v Regina [2000]
• Darker and Others v Chief Constable of the West Midlands [2000]
• Kuddus v Chief Constable of Leicestershire 2000

2001

• Z v United Kingdom [2001]
• A.B. and Others v Liverpool City Council and Others 2001
• Lister and Others v Hesley Hall Limited 2001
• Regina (August & Brown) versus Criminal Injuries Compensation Appeals Panel 2001
• C v Flintshire County Council 2001
• Cave v Robinson Jarvis and Rolf 2001
• Willian Hallam- Eames v Merrett Syndicates and Others 2001
• Brocklesby v Armitage and Guest 2001
• TP and KM v United Kingdom 2001
• Clunis v United Kingdom 2001

2002

• A v The London Borough Of Camden 2002
• G v Archbishop of Birmingham 2002
• Masterman-Lister v Brutton & Co. (Nos 1 and 2) [2002] Masterman-Lister v Jewell and Another 2003
• DP & JC v United Kingdom 2002
• Cave v Robinson Jarvis & Rolf (A Firm) 2002
• Miller v Martin and the Department of Social Services, State of Louisiana and Methodist home for children 2002
• Re F; F v Lambeth London Borough Council 2002
• HW (AP) v Criminal Injuries Compensation Appeals Panel 2002
• Dubai Aluminium Company Limited v Salaam 2002

2003

• Willemse v Hesp 2003
• D v East Berkshire Community Health NHS Trust, K and Another v Dewsbury Healthcare NHS Trust and Another, K and Another v Oldham NHS Trust and Another 2003
• McDonnell v Congregation of Christian Brothers Trustees and Others 2003
• KR and Others v Bryn Alyn Community (Holdings) Limited (In Liquidation) and Royal & Sun Alliance PLC 2003
• Mattis v Pollock (Trading as Flamingos Nightclub) 2003
• MB v British Columbia 2003
• KLB v British Columbia 2003
• A and Another v Essex County Council 2003
• R (on the application of M) v Criminal Injuries Compensation Appeals Panel 2003
• R (on the application of JE) v Criminal Injuries Compensation Appeals Panel 2003

2004

• Adams v Bracknell Forest Borough Council 2004
• Re T (Abuse: Standard of Proof) 2004
• Rose Wood & Others v Kirklees Metropolitan District Council versus Kirklees Metropolitan District Council 2004
• Bernard v Attorney General of Jamaica 2004
• Eagle v Chambers 2004
• R (on the Application of M) v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board 2004
• S v Advocate General 2004
• Richardson v Howie 2004
• R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Appeal Panel on the Application of CD and JM

2005

• A v The Archbishop Of Birmingham (1) The Trustees Of The Birmingham Archdiocese Of The Roman Catholic Church 2005
• L v London Borough Of Tower Hamlets 2005
• Kevin Raymond Young v Catholic Care And The Home Office 2005
• X v Y and Z (Unreported) 2005
• Hawley v Luminar Leisure Ltd & Ors 2005
• JD v East Berkshire Community Health NHS Trust and Others and Two Other Actions 2005
• Percy v Board of National Mission of The Church of Scotland 2005
• Malcolm New v Ministry of Defence 2005
• Blackwater v Plint 2005
• EB v Order of the Oblates of Mary Immaculate 2005
• Viasystems (Tyneside) Ltd v Thermal Transfer (Northern) Limited and Others 2005

2006

• A v Ioworth Hoare, H versus Suffolk County Council and The Secretary of State of Constitutional Affairs, X & Y versus London Borough of Wandsworth 2006
• A.B. and Others v The Nugent Care Society (Formerly Catholic Social Services (Liverpool)) 2006
• AD –and- OH (A Child: By AD His Litigation Friend) v Bury Metropolitan Council 2006
• Ronald Harry Bailey (By His Litigation Friend, Janet Ashton) v Matthew George Warren 2006
• C v D And Another 2006
• Corr (Administratrix Of The Estate Of Thomas Corr Deceased) v IBC Vehicles 2006
• Majrowski v Guy’s and St Thomas’ NHS Trust 2006
• KR and Others v Royal & Sun Alliance PLC 2006
• Amanda Lawson v Ann Glaves-Smith, Executor of the Estate of Christopher John Dawes Deceased 2006
• Marr v The Mayor and Burgesses of the London Borough of Lambeth and Others 2006
• KR and Others v Royal & Sun Alliance PLC 2006
• Meadow v General Medical Council 2006
• Manley v Commissioner of Police for the Metropolis 2006
• N v Chief Constable of Merseyside Police 2006

2007

• B v Reading Borough Council (1) Wokingham District Council (2) The Chief Constable of Thames Valley Police (3) 2007
• Richard Smith v Hampshire County Council 2007
• (1) Jason Stuart McCoubrey v Ministry of Defence 2007
• Jake Pierce v Doncaster Metropolitan Borough Council 2007
• Stephanie Lawrence v Pembrokeshire County Council 2007
• KXW, TXS and MXK v Robert Blackmore 2007
• J.M (AP) V Fife Council 2007
• Martins v Choudhary 2007

2008

• A v Hoare 2008
• A v Hoare, C v Middlesborough Council, X and Another v London Borough of Wandsworth, H v Suffolk County Council, Young v Catholic Care and Others 2008
• Albonetti v Wirral Metropolitan Borough Council 2008
• X (1) and Y (2) v The London Borough Of Hounslow 2008
• MB v London Borough of Ealing and Another 2008
• GR v Wirral Metropolitan Borough Council (Unreported) 2008
• TCD v Harrow Council, Worcestershire County Council, Birmingham City Council 2008
• Pierce v Doncaster Metropolitan Borough Council 2008
• D v Buckinghamshire County Council 2008
• In Re B (Children) 2008
• AT, NT, ML, AK v Dulghieru and Dulghieru 2008
• Bowden (AP) v Poor Sisters of Nazareth and others & Whitton v Poor Sisters of Nazareth and others 2008
• Chief Constable of Hertfordshire Police v Van Colle 2008
• Crowley v Surrey County Council 2008
• In Re E (A Child) 2008
• J K and P v Archbishop of Birmingham (1) The Trustees for the Birmingham Archdiocese of the Roman Catholic Church (2) Unreported (2008)
• Thompson v Archbishop of Liverpool and Others 2008
• RK and Another V United Kingdom 2008
• Savage v South Essex Partnership NHS Foundation Trust 2008
• TF v London Borough of Lewisham 2008
• Hinds v Liverpool County Court and Others 2008
• Corr (Administratrix of the estate of Thomas Corr) v IBC Vehicles Limited 2008
• Gravil v Carroll and Redruth Rugby Football Club 2008

2009

• A v Roman Catholic Archdiocese of Wellington and Others 2009
• Al v Finland 2009
• Bridge v Coventry City Council 2009
• Maga (By his Litigation Friend, The Official Solicitor to the Supreme Court) v Trustees of the Birmingham Archdiocese of the Roman Catholic Church 2009
• Mitchell and Another v Glasgow City Council 2009
• Raggett v The Society of Jesus Trust and Others 2009
• NXS v London Borough of Camden 2009
• AB and Others v Nugent Care Society: GR v Wirral Metropolitan Borough Council 2009
• R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Appeals Panel Ex Parte Tait 2009
• B v Reading Borough Council, Wokingham District Council and the Chief Constable of Thames Valley Police 2009
• Thompson v Archbishop of Liverpool and others 2009
• McDonnell and Another v Walker 2009
• X and Y v London Borough of Hounslow 2009
• R (VA) v Criminal Injuries Compensation Appeals Panel 2009

2010

• BJM v Eyre, Hawthorne, Loram and Riley 2010
• G v Neath Port Talbot County Borough Council and Others 2010
• AD and OD v United Kingdom 2010
• MAGA v Trustees of the Birmingham Archdiocese of the Roman Catholic Church 2010
• AB and Others v Nugent Care 2010
• Merthyr Tydfil County Borough Council v C 2010
• XA v YA 2010
• Webster and Others v Ridgeway Foundation School 2010
• VL v Oxfordshire County Council 2010
• Various Claimants v The Catholic Child Welfare Society and Others 2010
• Rabone and Rabone v Pennine Care NHS Trust 2010
• AB and Others v Nugent Care Society 2010
• Raggett v Society of Jesus 1929 and Others 2010
• XA v YA 2010
• CICA v CICB (Irene Lamb)
• Brinks Global Services Inc and Others v Igrox Limited and Another 2010

2011

• A (A Child) v Leeds City Council 2011
• ABB and Others v Milton Keynes Council 2011
• JGE v The English Province and Others 2011
• Batley and Others v Roe, Rose and Norfolk County Council 2011
• EB v John Haughton 2011
• Jones and Lovegrove v Ruth and Ruth 2011
• R v D(N), P(A), U(S) Court of Appeal Criminal Division 2011
• Hutton v Criminal Injuries Compensation Authority 2011
• ABB and Others v Milton Keynes Council 2011
• R V D(N), P(A), U(S) Court of Appeal Criminal Division 2011

2012

• EL v The Children’s Society 2012
• XVW & YZA v Gravesend Grammar School and Another 2012

• Aggravated damages
• CICA - Compensation going to abuser
• CICA - Conduct
• CICA - Consanguinity
• CICA - crime of violence
• CICA - directly attributable
• CICA - Duty to give reasons for decision
• CICA - effect of previous convictions on Applicant
• CICA - living with member of own family
• CICA - Multiple incidents of abuse
• CICA - No prosecution
• CICA - Reporting to police
• CICA - Res Iudicata
• CICA - Time Limits
• CICA -Consent
• Costs
• Death of claimant
• Disclosure
• Duty of care
• Educational negligence
• Evidence
• Exemplary Damages
• Human Rights
• Insurance
• Limitation
• Loss of earnings capacity
• Mental capacity
• Misfeasance in Public Office
• Negligence
• Preliminary Issue on Limitation
• Procedure
• Quantum
• Standard of care
• Standard of proof
• Vicarious liability
• Witness Immunity

Aggravated damages

• Richardson v Howie 2004

CICA - Compensation going to abuser

• R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board ex parte JM B-M 1998
• R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board ex parte Brown Murphy 1997

CICA - Conduct

• R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Appeal Panel on the Application of CD and JM
• R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board ex parte Cook 1996

CICA - Consanguinity

• P’s Curator Bonis v CICB 1997
• P’s Curator Bonis v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board 1997

CICA - crime of violence

• LC v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board 1999
• R (on the application of JE) v Criminal Injuries Compensation Appeals Panel 2003
• R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Appeals Panel Ex Parte Tait 2009
• R v CICB ex parte Webb and Others 1986

CICA - directly attributable

• R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board ex parte Walls 1999
• R v CICB ex parte Kent and Milne
• R v CICB ex parte Ince 1973

CICA - Duty to give reasons for decision

• R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Authority ex Parte Leatherland 1998
• R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board ex parte Reid 1996

CICA - effect of previous convictions on Applicant

• R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board ex parte Maxted

CICA - living with member of own family

• R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board 1993
• P’s Curator Bonis v CICB 1997
• R v CICB ex parte Richardson [1996] CLY 1447
• R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board ex parte Staten 1972
• S v Advocate General 2004
• R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board ex parte Dickenson 1995
• R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board ex parte 1995
• P’s Curator Bonis v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board 1997
• RP and TG v Home Office and CICB 1994
• R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board 1993
• R v CICB ex parte Fox 1972
• R (on the Application of M) v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board 2004

CICA - Multiple incidents of abuse

• R v Secretary of State for Home Department, ex parte C 1999

CICA - No prosecution

• HW (AP) v Criminal Injuries Compensation Appeals Panel 2002

CICA - Reporting to police

• Regina v CICB ex parte A House of Lords 25th March 1999
• R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board ex parte Powell 1993
• R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board ex parte Salt 1999
• R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board ex parte Cobb 1995
• R (VA) v Criminal Injuries Compensation Appeals Panel 2009
• R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board ex parte Reid 1996

CICA - Res Iudicata

• Re G (A Ward)(Criminal Injuries Compensation)1993
• Re G (a ward) (Criminal Injuries : Compensation) 1993

CICA - Time Limits

• X v CICB 1999
• Hutton v Criminal Injuries Compensation Authority 2011
• R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board ex parte 20th February 1992
• X v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board 1999
• R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board 1993
• R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board ex parte Wilson 1991
• R (on the application of M) v Criminal Injuries Compensation Appeals Panel 2003

CICA -Consent

• R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Appeal Panel on the Application of CD and JM
• R v CICB ex parte Piercy 1997
• Regina (August & Brown) versus Criminal Injuries Compensation Appeals Panel 2001

Costs

• L v London Borough Of Tower Hamlets 2005

Death of claimant

• Corr (Administratrix Of The Estate Of Thomas Corr Deceased) v IBC Vehicles 2006

Disclosure

• D v Buckinghamshire County Council 2008

Duty of care

• AD –and- OH (A Child: By AD His Litigation Friend) v Bury Metropolitan Council 2006
• B v Reading Borough Council (1) Wokingham District Council (2) The Chief Constable of Thames Valley Police (3) 2007
• D v East Berkshire Community Health NHS Trust, K and Another v Dewsbury Healthcare NHS Trust and Another, K and Another v Oldham NHS Trust and Another 2003
• H v Norfolk 1997
• JD v East Berkshire Community Health NHS Trust and Others and Two Other Actions 2005
• S v Gloucestershire County Council; L v The London Borough of Tower Hamlets and London Borough of Havering [2000]
• Stephanie Lawrence v Pembrokeshire County Council 2007
• W 1 – 6 v Essex County Council and Another 1998
• W 1 – 6 v Essex County Council and Another 2000
• X (Minors) v Bedfordshire County Council, M (A Minor) And Another v Newham London Borough Council And Others, E (A Minor) v Dorset County Council, Chirstmas v Hampshire County Council, Keating v Bromley London Borough Council 1995
• Barrett v London Borough Of Enfield 1999
• X (1) and Y (2) v The London Borough Of Hounslow 2008
• G v Neath Port Talbot County Borough Council and Others 2010
• X and Y v London Borough of Hounslow 2009
• A (A Child) v Leeds City Council 2011
• MAGA v Trustees of the Birmingham Archdiocese of the Roman Catholic Church 2010
• A and Another v Essex County Council 2003
• Merthyr Tydfil County Borough Council v C 2010
• Brinks Global Services Inc and Others v Igrox Limited and Another 2010
• ABB and Others v Milton Keynes Council 2011
• XVW & YZA v Gravesend Grammar School and Another 2012
• VL v Oxfordshire County Council 2010
• XA v YA 2010

Educational negligence

• Marr v The Mayor and Burgesses of the London Borough of Lambeth and Others 2006
• Phelps v London Borough of Hillingdon 1998
• Phelps v London Borough of Hillingdon, Anderton v Clwyd County Council, in Re G (A Minor) By His Next Friend, Jarvis v Hampshire County Council [2000]
• Crowley v Surrey County Council 2008
• Webster and Others v Ridgeway Foundation School 2010

Evidence

• Al v Finland 2009
• R V D(N), P(A), U(S) Court of Appeal Criminal Division 2011

Exemplary Damages

• Kuddus v Chief Constable of Leicestershire 2000
• Rookes v Barnard 1964

Human Rights

• AD and OD v United Kingdom 2010
• TP and KM v United Kingdom 2001
• Clunis v United Kingdom 2001
• Rabone and Rabone v Pennine Care NHS Trust 2010
• Stuart v United Kingdom 1999

Insurance

• KR and Others v Royal & Sun Alliance PLC 2006
• KR and Others v Royal & Sun Alliance PLC 2006

Limitation

• A v Hoare 2008
• A v Hoare, C v Middlesborough Council, X and Another v London Borough of Wandsworth, H v Suffolk County Council, Young v Catholic Care and Others 2008
• A v Ioworth Hoare, H versus Suffolk County Council and The Secretary of State of Constitutional Affairs, X & Y versus London Borough of Wandsworth 2006
• A v The London Borough Of Camden 2002
• A.B. and Others v The Nugent Care Society (Formerly Catholic Social Services (Liverpool)) 2006
• A.B. and Others v Liverpool City Council and Others 2001
• Adams v Bracknell Forest Borough Council 2004
• Albonetti v Wirral Metropolitan Borough Council 2008
• Kevin Raymond Young v Catholic Care And The Home Office 2005
• Richard Smith v Hampshire County Council 2007
• G v Archbishop of Birmingham 2002
• (1) Jason Stuart McCoubrey v Ministry of Defence 2007
• McDonnell v Congregation of Christian Brothers Trustees and Others 2003
• KR and Others v Bryn Alyn Community (Holdings) Limited (In Liquidation) and Royal & Sun Alliance PLC 2003
• Rose Wood & Others v Kirklees Metropolitan District Council versus Kirklees Metropolitan District Council 2004
• GR v Wirral Metropolitan Borough Council (Unreported) 2008
• TCD v Harrow Council, Worcestershire County Council, Birmingham City Council 2008
• Bowden (AP) v Poor Sisters of Nazareth and others & Whitton v Poor Sisters of Nazareth and others 2008
• Stubbings v Webb 1993
• Bridge v Coventry City Council 2009
• Raggett v The Society of Jesus Trust and Others 2009
• Das v Ganju 1999
• Dobbie v Medway Health Authority 1994
• NXS v London Borough of Camden 2009
• AB and Others v Nugent Care Society: GR v Wirral Metropolitan Borough Council 2009
• Forbes v Wandsworth Health Authority 1996
• S v W [1994]
• Arnold v Central Electricity Generating Board [1987]
• Broadley V Guy Clapham & Co. 1994
• Yates v Thakeham Tiles Limited 1994
• Whitfield v North Durham Health Authority 1994
• Coad v Cornwall and Isles of Scilly Health Authority 1996
• Stubbings and Others v United Kingdom 1996
• Cave v Robinson Jarvis and Rolf 2001
• Willian Hallam- Eames v Merrett Syndicates and Others 2001
• Brocklesby v Armitage and Guest 2001
• Cave v Robinson Jarvis & Rolf (A Firm) 2002
• Donovan v Gwentoys Ltd 1990
• Hartley v Birmingham City District Council 1992
• Long v Tolchard & Sons Ltd 1999
• Nash and Others v Eli Lilly & Co. and Others 1993
• Halford v Brooks and Another 1991
• Farthing v North East Essex Health Authority 1997
• BJM v Eyre, Hawthorne, Loram and Riley 2010
• McDonnell and Another v Walker 2009
• Batley and Others v Roe, Rose and Norfolk County Council 2011
• AB and Others v Nugent Care 2010
• Raggett v Society of Jesus 1929 and Others 2010
• XA v YA 2010
• CICA v CICB (Irene Lamb)
• EB v John Haughton 2011
• R v L.P.B 1990
• EL v The Children’s Society 2012

Loss of earnings capacity

• Blamire v South Cumbria Health Authority 1993
• Willemse v Hesp 2003

Mental capacity

• Masterman-Lister v Brutton & Co. (Nos 1 and 2) [2002] Masterman-Lister v Jewell and Another 2003
• Ronald Harry Bailey (By His Litigation Friend, Janet Ashton) v Matthew George Warren 2006
• Maga (By his Litigation Friend, The Official Solicitor to the Supreme Court) v Trustees of the Birmingham Archdiocese of the Roman Catholic Church 2009
• MAGA v Trustees of the Birmingham Archdiocese of the Roman Catholic Church 2010
• Yonge v Toynbee 1909

Misfeasance in Public Office

• Darker and Others v Chief Constable of the West Midlands [2000]
• B v Reading Borough Council, Wokingham District Council and the Chief Constable of Thames Valley Police 2009

Negligence

• Pierce v Doncaster Metropolitan Borough Council 2008
• DP & JC v United Kingdom 2002
• Mitchell and Another v Glasgow City Council 2009
• Surtees v Kingston Upon Thames Borough Council 1991
• RK and Another V United Kingdom 2008
• TF v London Borough of Lewisham 2008
• Z v United Kingdom [2001]
• Chief Constable of Hertfordshire Police v Van Colle 2008
• In Re E (A Child) 2008
• Maga (By his Litigation Friend, The Official Solicitor to the Supreme Court) v Trustees of the Birmingham Archdiocese of the Roman Catholic Church 2009
• Savage v South Essex Partnership NHS Foundation Trust 2008
• Hill v Chief Constable of West Yorkshire 1987
• Hinds v Liverpool County Court and Others 2008
• Osman v United Kingdom 1998
• A and Another v Essex County Council 2003
• Merthyr Tydfil County Borough Council v C 2010

Preliminary Issue on Limitation

• J K and P v Archbishop of Birmingham (1) The Trustees for the Birmingham Archdiocese of the Roman Catholic Church (2) Unreported (2008)
• Thompson v Archbishop of Liverpool and Others 2008
• Thompson v Archbishop of Liverpool and others 2009
• AB and Others v Nugent Care Society 2010

Procedure

• A B & Others v Liverpool City Council, The Nugent Care Society, Trustees of The National Children’s Home and Orphanage Registered 1998

Quantum

• A v The Archbishop Of Birmingham (1) The Trustees Of The Birmingham Archdiocese Of The Roman Catholic Church 2005
• C v D And Another 2006
• Griffiths v Williams 1995
• KXW, TXS and MXK v Robert Blackmore 2007
• Malcolm New v Ministry of Defence 2005
• MB v London Borough of Ealing and Another 2008
• Various Claimants v Flintshire County Council 2000
• Various Claimants v Leicestershire County Council 1996
• X v Y and Z (Unreported) 2005
• Amanda Lawson v Ann Glaves-Smith, Executor of the Estate of Christopher John Dawes Deceased 2006
• AT, NT, ML, AK v Dulghieru and Dulghieru 2008
• C v Flintshire County Council 2001
• J.M (AP) V Fife Council 2007
• Manley v Commissioner of Police for the Metropolis 2006
• Jones and Lovegrove v Ruth and Ruth 2011
• Martins v Choudhary 2007
• Bridge v Coventry City Council 2009
• KR and Others v Bryn Alyn Community (Holdings) Limited (In Liquidation) and Royal & Sun Alliance PLC 2003
• Jake Pierce v Doncaster Metropolitan Borough Council 2007
• AB and Others v Nugent Care 2010
• Eagle v Chambers 2004
• Corr (Administratrix of the estate of Thomas Corr) v IBC Vehicles Limited 2008
• BJM v Eyre, Hawthorne, Loram and Riley 2010
• Richardson v Howie 2004
• ABB and Others v Milton Keynes Council 2011

Standard of care

• Jake Pierce v Doncaster Metropolitan Borough Council 2007
• Re F; F v Lambeth London Borough Council 2002

Standard of proof

• Re T (Abuse: Standard of Proof) 2004
• In Re B (Children) 2008

Vicarious liability

• Hawley v Luminar Leisure Ltd & Ors 2005
• Lister and Others v Hesley Hall Limited 2001
• Majrowski v Guy’s and St Thomas’ NHS Trust 2006
• Mattis v Pollock (Trading as Flamingos Nightclub) 2003
• Percy v Board of National Mission of The Church of Scotland 2005
• Sargent v Walsall Metropolitan Borough Council And Others 1985
• Bazley v Curry 1999
• Jacobi v Griffiths 1999
• Brooks v Regina [2000]
• Blackwater v Plint 2005
• MB v British Columbia 2003
• EB v Order of the Oblates of Mary Immaculate 2005
• KLB v British Columbia 2003
• A v Roman Catholic Archdiocese of Wellington and Others 2009
• N v Chief Constable of Merseyside Police 2006
• Gravil v Carroll and Redruth Rugby Football Club 2008
• MAGA v Trustees of the Birmingham Archdiocese of the Roman Catholic Church 2010
• Bernard v Attorney General of Jamaica 2004
• Miller v Martin and the Department of Social Services, State of Louisiana and Methodist home for children 2002
• Various Claimants v The Catholic Child Welfare Society and Others 2010
• Viasystems (Tyneside) Ltd v Thermal Transfer (Northern) Limited and Others 2005
• Dubai Aluminium Company Limited v Salaam 2002
• EL v The Children’s Society 2012
• XVW & YZA v Gravesend Grammar School and Another 2012
• JGE v The English Province and Others 2011

Witness Immunity

• Meadow v General Medical Council 2006
• Hinds v Liverpool County Court and Others 2008

• County Court
• Court of Appeal
• Court of Appeal Civil Division
• Court of Session
• Criminal Appeals
• Criminal Injuries Appeals Panel Upper Tribunal
• Crown Court
• Divisional Court
• England and Wales Court of Appeal
• England and Wales High Court
• European Court of Human Rights
• High Court
• High Court (Queens Bench)
• House of Lords
• Queen's Bench
• Louisiana Supreme Court
• Outer House
• Outer House of the Court of Session
• Outer House, Court of Session
• Outer Session
• Personal Injury and Quanturn Reports
• Queen's Bench
• Queens bench division
• Supreme Court of Canada
• unknown
• Unreported
• unreported
• Court of Appeal

County Court

• GR v Wirral Metropolitan Borough Council (Unreported) 2008
• KXW, TXS and MXK v Robert Blackmore 2007
• TF v London Borough of Lewisham 2008
• X v Y and Z (Unreported) 2005

Court of Appeal

• (1) Jason Stuart McCoubrey v Ministry of Defence 2007
• A B & Others v Liverpool City Council, The Nugent Care Society, Trustees of The National Children’s Home and Orphanage Registered 1998
• A v Ioworth Hoare, H versus Suffolk County Council and The Secretary of State of Constitutional Affairs, X & Y versus London Borough of Wandsworth 2006
• AB and Others v Nugent Care Society: GR v Wirral Metropolitan Borough Council 2009
• AD –and- OH (A Child: By AD His Litigation Friend) v Bury Metropolitan Council 2006
• Albonetti v Wirral Metropolitan Borough Council 2008
• B v Reading Borough Council (1) Wokingham District Council (2) The Chief Constable of Thames Valley Police (3) 2007
• C v Flintshire County Council 2001
• Cave v Robinson Jarvis and Rolf 2001
• Corr (Administratrix Of The Estate Of Thomas Corr Deceased) v IBC Vehicles 2006
• D v Buckinghamshire County Council 2008
• D v East Berkshire Community Health NHS Trust, K and Another v Dewsbury Healthcare NHS Trust and Another, K and Another v Oldham NHS Trust and Another 2003
• Das v Ganju 1999
• Dobbie v Medway Health Authority 1994
• Forbes v Wandsworth Health Authority 1996
• Griffiths v Williams 1995
• Brocklesby v Armitage and Guest 2001
• Hartley v Birmingham City District Council 1992
• Long v Tolchard & Sons Ltd 1999
• Nash and Others v Eli Lilly & Co. and Others 1993
• Halford v Brooks and Another 1991
• Masterman-Lister v Brutton & Co. (Nos 1 and 2) [2002] Masterman-Lister v Jewell and Another 2003
• Mattis v Pollock (Trading as Flamingos Nightclub) 2003
• Phelps v London Borough of Hillingdon 1998
• Pierce v Doncaster Metropolitan Borough Council 2008
• Re T (Abuse: Standard of Proof) 2004
• Richard Smith v Hampshire County Council 2007
• Ronald Harry Bailey (By His Litigation Friend, Janet Ashton) v Matthew George Warren 2006
• S v Gloucestershire County Council; L v The London Borough of Tower Hamlets and London Borough of Havering [2000]
• S v W [1994]
• Sargent v Walsall Metropolitan Borough Council And Others 1985
• Stephanie Lawrence v Pembrokeshire County Council 2007
• Whitfield v North Durham Health Authority 1994
• Willemse v Hesp 2003
• Yates v Thakeham Tiles Limited 1994
• Farthing v North East Essex Health Authority 1997
• McDonnell and Another v Walker 2009
• X and Y v London Borough of Hounslow 2009
• G v Neath Port Talbot County Borough Council and Others 2010
• Hutton v Criminal Injuries Compensation Authority 2011
• A (A Child) v Leeds City Council 2011
• Eagle v Chambers 2004
• Various Claimants v The Catholic Child Welfare Society and Others 2010
• Raggett v Society of Jesus 1929 and Others 2010
• CICA v CICB (Irene Lamb)
• R v CICB ex parte Ince 1973
• R v CICB ex parte Webb and Others 1986
• RP and TG v Home Office and CICB 1994
• R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board ex parte JM B-M 1998
• R (on the application of JE) v Criminal Injuries Compensation Appeals Panel 2003
• Jones and Lovegrove v Ruth and Ruth 2011
• Richardson v Howie 2004
• Viasystems (Tyneside) Ltd v Thermal Transfer (Northern) Limited and Others 2005
• Brinks Global Services Inc and Others v Igrox Limited and Another 2010
• Martins v Choudhary 2007
• R v D(N), P(A), U(S) Court of Appeal Criminal Division 2011
• Re G (A Ward)(Criminal Injuries Compensation)1993
• R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board 1993
• R V D(N), P(A), U(S) Court of Appeal Criminal Division 2011

Court of Appeal Civil Division

• Gravil v Carroll and Redruth Rugby Football Club 2008
• Kuddus v Chief Constable of Leicestershire 2000
• Manley v Commissioner of Police for the Metropolis 2006

Court of Session

• J.M (AP) V Fife Council 2007

Criminal Appeals

• R v L.P.B 1990

Criminal Injuries Appeals Panel Upper Tribunal

• R (VA) v Criminal Injuries Compensation Appeals Panel 2009

Crown Court

• Rose Wood & Others v Kirklees Metropolitan District Council versus Kirklees Metropolitan District Council 2004

Divisional Court

• R v CICB ex parte Fox 1972

England and Wales Court of Appeal

• Rabone and Rabone v Pennine Care NHS Trust 2010

England and Wales High Court

• R (on the Application of M) v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board 2004
• R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board ex parte Salt 1999
• R (on the application of M) v Criminal Injuries Compensation Appeals Panel 2003

European Court of Human Rights

• Al v Finland 2009
• DP & JC v United Kingdom 2002
• Stubbings and Others v United Kingdom 1996
• Z v United Kingdom [2001]
• Osman v United Kingdom 1998
• Stuart v United Kingdom 1999

High Court

• R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Appeals Panel Ex Parte Tait 2009
• Meadow v General Medical Council 2006
• Hinds v Liverpool County Court and Others 2008
• AB and Others v Nugent Care 2010
• R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Authority ex Parte Leatherland 1998
• BJM v Eyre, Hawthorne, Loram and Riley 2010
• ABB and Others v Milton Keynes Council 2011
• XA v YA 2010
• Webster and Others v Ridgeway Foundation School 2010
• VL v Oxfordshire County Council 2010
• AB and Others v Nugent Care Society 2010
• XA v YA 2010
• EB v John Haughton 2011
• R v CICB ex parte Richardson [1996] CLY 1447
• R v CICB ex parte Piercy 1997
• R v CICB ex parte Kent and Milne
• R v Secretary of State for Home Department, ex parte C 1999
• P’s Curator Bonis v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board 1997
• R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Appeal Panel on the Application of CD and JM
• JGE v The English Province and Others 2011
• EL v The Children’s Society 2012
• ABB and Others v Milton Keynes Council 2011
• XVW & YZA v Gravesend Grammar School and Another 2012

High Court (Queens Bench)

• N v Chief Constable of Merseyside Police 2006

House of Lords

• McDonnell v Congregation of Christian Brothers Trustees and Others 2003
• A v Hoare, C v Middlesborough Council, X and Another v London Borough of Wandsworth, H v Suffolk County Council, Young v Catholic Care and Others 2008
• Adams v Bracknell Forest Borough Council 2004
• Barrett v London Borough Of Enfield 1999
• Bowden (AP) v Poor Sisters of Nazareth and others & Whitton v Poor Sisters of Nazareth and others 2008
• Chief Constable of Hertfordshire Police v Van Colle 2008
• In Re B (Children) 2008
• In Re E (A Child) 2008
• JD v East Berkshire Community Health NHS Trust and Others and Two Other Actions 2005
• Cave v Robinson Jarvis & Rolf (A Firm) 2002
• Donovan v Gwentoys Ltd 1990
• Lister and Others v Hesley Hall Limited 2001
• Majrowski v Guy’s and St Thomas’ NHS Trust 2006
• Mitchell and Another v Glasgow City Council 2009
• Percy v Board of National Mission of The Church of Scotland 2005
• Phelps v London Borough of Hillingdon, Anderton v Clwyd County Council, in Re G (A Minor) By His Next Friend, Jarvis v Hampshire County Council [2000]
• Savage v South Essex Partnership NHS Foundation Trust 2008
• W 1 – 6 v Essex County Council and Another 2000
• Darker and Others v Chief Constable of the West Midlands [2000]
• Hill v Chief Constable of West Yorkshire 1987
• Regina v CICB ex parte A House of Lords 25th March 1999
• Corr (Administratrix of the estate of Thomas Corr) v IBC Vehicles Limited 2008
• Rookes v Barnard 1964
• Dubai Aluminium Company Limited v Salaam 2002

Queen's Bench

• C v D And Another 2006

Louisiana Supreme Court

• Miller v Martin and the Department of Social Services, State of Louisiana and Methodist home for children 2002

Outer House

• R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board ex parte Walls 1999

Outer House of the Court of Session

• LC v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board 1999

Outer House, Court of Session

• X v CICB 1999
• HW (AP) v Criminal Injuries Compensation Appeals Panel 2002

Outer Session

• P’s Curator Bonis v CICB 1997

Personal Injury and Quanturn Reports

• R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board 1993

Queen's Bench

• A v Hoare 2008
• A v The Archbishop Of Birmingham (1) The Trustees Of The Birmingham Archdiocese Of The Roman Catholic Church 2005
• A.B. and Others v The Nugent Care Society (Formerly Catholic Social Services (Liverpool)) 2006
• Amanda Lawson v Ann Glaves-Smith, Executor of the Estate of Christopher John Dawes Deceased 2006
• AT, NT, ML, AK v Dulghieru and Dulghieru 2008
• C v D And Another 2006
• Crowley v Surrey County Council 2008
• Hawley v Luminar Leisure Ltd & Ors 2005
• Jake Pierce v Doncaster Metropolitan Borough Council 2007
• KR and Others v Bryn Alyn Community (Holdings) Limited (In Liquidation) and Royal & Sun Alliance PLC 2003
• KR and Others v Royal & Sun Alliance PLC 2006
• KR and Others v Royal & Sun Alliance PLC 2006
• Malcolm New v Ministry of Defence 2005
• Marr v The Mayor and Burgesses of the London Borough of Lambeth and Others 2006
• MB v London Borough of Ealing and Another 2008
• NXS v London Borough of Camden 2009
• Raggett v The Society of Jesus Trust and Others 2009
• Regina (August & Brown) versus Criminal Injuries Compensation Appeals Panel 2001
• TCD v Harrow Council, Worcestershire County Council, Birmingham City Council 2008
• W 1 – 6 v Essex County Council and Another 1998
• X (1) and Y (2) v The London Borough Of Hounslow 2008

Queens bench division

• B v Reading Borough Council, Wokingham District Council and the Chief Constable of Thames Valley Police 2009

Supreme Court of Canada

• Bazley v Curry 1999
• Blackwater v Plint 2005
• EB v Order of the Oblates of Mary Immaculate 2005
• Jacobi v Griffiths 1999
• KLB v British Columbia 2003
• MB v British Columbia 2003

unknown

• R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board ex parte 1995
• R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board ex parte Dickenson 1995

Unreported

• Batley and Others v Roe, Rose and Norfolk County Council 2011

unreported

• R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board ex parte Maxted
• R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board ex parte Brown Murphy 1997
• R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board ex parte Cook 1996
• R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board ex parte Powell 1993
• Re F; F v Lambeth London Borough Council 2002
• Re G (a ward) (Criminal Injuries : Compensation) 1993
• R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board ex parte Wilson 1991

Court of Appeal

• R v CICB ex parte Webb and Others 1986